Serdar Yegulalp">
Psycho Drive-In logo
Search
  • PDI Press
    Featured
    • Q Clearance

      Serdar Yegulalp
      March 4, 2021
      Fiction, PDI Press Writers
    Recent
    • Q Clearance

      Mike Burr
      March 4, 2021
    • ON SALE NOW! NOIRLATHOTEP 2: MORE TALES OF LOVECRAFTIAN CRIME!!

      psychodr
      December 31, 2018
    • VOICES FROM THE NIGHT: The Living Dead Tell Their Stories

      John E. Meredith
      October 31, 2018
    • PDI Press Catalog
    • PDI Press Writers
      • Fiction
  • Columns A-D
    • A Fistful of Dollar Comics
    • ABCs of Horror
    • All Binge… No Purge
    • Anything Joes
    • Beautiful Creatures
    • Big Eyes Smart Mouth
    • Big Sleeps and Long Goodbyes
    • Cahiers du Horror
    • Dispatches From the Field
    • Drive-In Saturday
    • Dungeons & D-Listers
  • Columns F-P
    • The Final Girl
    • First Looks… Second Thoughts
    • The Flesh is Weak
    • Innocence and Experience
    • Lost in Translation
    • Page to Screen
    • Popcorn Cinema
    • Psycho Essentials: The ’80s!
  • Columns S-Z
    • Schlock & Awe
    • Shakespeare on Film
    • Shot for Shot
    • Sick Flix
    • Unnatural Selections
    • Versus
    • Video Word Made Flesh
    • We Got Lists
    • Women in Horror
    • The Xeno File
    • Zombies 101
  • Reviews
    Featured
    • Chaos Walking (2021)

      Serdar Yegulalp
      April 13, 2021
      Movies, Reviews
    Recent
    • Chaos Walking (2021)

      Nate Zoebl
      April 13, 2021
    • Godzilla vs. Kong (2021)

      Paul Brian McCoy
      April 2, 2021
    • Zack Snyder’s Justice League: A Review, Comparison, and Breakdown

      Paul Brian McCoy
      March 24, 2021
    • Books
    • DVD/Blu-ray
    • Movies
    • TV
    • Series
  • Interviews
    Featured
    • Interview with Indie Horror Master, Chris Bickel

      Serdar Yegulalp
      July 13, 2018
      Interviews
    Recent
    • Interview with Indie Horror Master, Chris Bickel

      The Final Girl
      July 13, 2018
    • David Black: Carnies, Carnage, and the Creative Chaos of Darkness Visible

      Dan Lee
      March 7, 2017
    • Jaiden Kaine joins the Marvel Universe as new Luke Cage baddie, Zip

      Andre Lamar
      September 29, 2016
    • SDCC 2016 Interviews: The Cast and Creators of Batman: The Killing Joke

      Jason Sacks
      July 28, 2016
    • SDCC 2016 Interviews: The Cast and Creators of Syfy’s Van Helsing

      Dave Hearn, Paul Brian McCoy
      July 27, 2016
    • Wondercon Interview: The Cast of Damien

      Gary Richardson, Laura Akers
      April 16, 2016
  • News
    Featured
    • John Wick: Chapter 3 – Parabellum arrives on Digital 8/23 and 4K Ultra HD, Blu-ray, DVD and On Demand 9/10

      Serdar Yegulalp
      July 30, 2019
      DVD/Blu-ray, News
    Recent
    • John Wick: Chapter 3 – Parabellum arrives on Digital 8/23 and 4K Ultra HD, Blu-ray, DVD and On Demand 9/10

      psychodr
      July 30, 2019
    • X-Men: Dark Phoenix arrives on Digital 9/3 and 4K Ultra HD, Blu-ray and DVD 9/17

      Paul Brian McCoy
      July 16, 2019
    • Avengers: Endgame arrives on Digital 7/30 and Blu-ray 8/13

      psychodr
      July 16, 2019
    • Trailers
  • Psychos
  • Merchandise
Breaking
  • Chaos Walking (2021)
  • Godzilla vs. Kong (2021)
  • Zack Snyder’s Justice League: A Review, Comparison, and Breakdown
  • Psycho Goreman (2021)
  • Advance Review: Bad Girls (2021)
  • Shadow in the Cloud (2020)
  • RSS
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Tumblr
  • Who We Be
  • Contact
  • PDI Press
    • PDI Press Catalog
    • PDI Press Writers
      • Fiction
  • Columns A-D
    • A Fistful of Dollar Comics
    • ABCs of Horror
    • All Binge… No Purge
    • Anything Joes
    • Beautiful Creatures
    • Big Eyes Smart Mouth
    • Big Sleeps and Long Goodbyes
    • Cahiers du Horror
    • Dispatches From the Field
    • Drive-In Saturday
    • Dungeons & D-Listers
  • Columns F-P
    • The Final Girl
    • First Looks… Second Thoughts
    • The Flesh is Weak
    • Innocence and Experience
    • Lost in Translation
    • Page to Screen
    • Popcorn Cinema
    • Psycho Essentials: The ’80s!
  • Columns S-Z
    • Schlock & Awe
    • Shakespeare on Film
    • Shot for Shot
    • Sick Flix
    • Unnatural Selections
    • Versus
    • Video Word Made Flesh
    • We Got Lists
    • Women in Horror
    • The Xeno File
    • Zombies 101
  • Reviews
    • Books
    • DVD/Blu-ray
    • Movies
    • TV
    • Series
  • Interviews
  • News
    • Trailers
  • Psychos
  • Merchandise
Home
Columns
Big Eyes Smart Mouth

Scarlett Johannson And The Half-Shelled ‘Ghost’

Serdar Yegulalp
January 7, 2015
Big Eyes Smart Mouth

Even if it’s not a wholly done deal, the fact that Scarlett Johansson has signed on as Motoko Kusanagi for a live-action Hollywood adaptation of Ghost in the Shell courtesy of DreamWorks SKG is the strongest evidence yet that said project will get the green light. It’s also the strongest evidence yet of how misguided the whole affair is, and how Hollywood’s thinking about anything sourced from Asia — live-action or animated — remains blinkered by its own timidity and lack of imagination.

I’ve written before about what folly might ensue if this project went ahead outside of Japan. I was not thrilled with the idea then, and I remained unthrilled with it now for all the same reasons and more. The original reasons were mainly aesthetic: you can’t take a story set in Japan, rooted in that country’s history and aesthetics, and transport it to the West without losing, well, everything. Any Western remake of AKIRA was also likely to suffer from the same issues, but at last report that ill-conceived and disrespectful project is still grinding along, too.

Three ways to fail

Casting Johansson for Shell, though, adds new reasons to feel uneasy: that this project would end up becoming a race-washed mess, one where Western/white actors are dragooned in to sell the results to audiences that allegedly won’t sit still for anything but familiar faces (something Donna Dickens of HitFix also shook her head at). This is a prophecy that is both self-perpetuating and self-fulfilling — and all the more surprising in the light of how a greater proportion of production money and revenue for modern A-list blockbusters comes from overseas in the first place.

Assuming this production does get out of drydock, three possibilities present themselves for how the final product could turn out:

The Whitewash. In this version, Johansson isn’t the only Anglo/Western actor; the rest of the cast — or at least the top tier — is also filled out with familiar names so as not to scare off timid audiences. In the case of the character Batou, Kusanagi’s muscled-up male cohort, this might be justifiable, since his character was allegedly an homage to Steven Seagal in the first place. But it’s still shortsighted, doubly so when names like Rinko Kikuchi and Ken Watanabe are routinely appearing in major Hollywood productions with plenty of screentime and dialogue apiece. Unfortunately, they aren’t seen as being “bankable” — a notion I find all the sillier in the light of how more movies these days are sold by concept and imagery, not casting.

The Retrofit. Also known as “The AKIRA Approach”. In this version, the story — with or without its names intact — is crated up as-is and transported to a Western setting. Some of what made Shell special might be reconnected with the West, but I don’t expect this to be any less clumsy than the way the AKIRA remake tried to substitute 9/11 for Hiroshima. This version may not be as egregious in terms of its racial politics, but aesthetically, it’s still a mangle job.

The Voice-Only Version. The least likely version to be made, but also the one likely to be least egregious. In this version, the production ends up being CGI-assisted to such a degree that all that remains of Johannson & Co. is mocap and voices. Such a thing could be redubbed in Japan, for instance (one of its original target audiences anyway), without too much trouble. But all signs point to this being a full-blown live-action vehicle, and not a halfway-house of digital and real-world work, and it still skirts over the central issues of who this thing is being made for and why.

In fact, there’s an easy enough answer to that question: this movie isn’t being made for “the fans”. It’s being made for a mainstream, paying, and ostensibly Western audience. But unless Ghost is either stretched or cropped to fit on the Procrustean bed of such a market, it can’t get made — not at the budget and scale it deserves, anyway.

Ghost in the shell, or worms from the can?

I’m not sure any live-action adaptation of an anime property can succeed — in the sense of garnering enough box-office draw to justify its likely pricey investment — if the fact that it has a fandom is a primary motivation for making it. Too many of the properties brought up for anime/manga-to-live-action projects are fan favorites that have little to no chance of being adapted coherently. That they are fan favorites seems to be what motivates acquiring the rights in the first place, not that the stories lend themselves to being adapted well to a mainstream movie. (I’ve speculated before that this might be one of the side effects of some of the former generation of fans getting into positions of power: now that they can make these things happen, they’re not thinking as carefully about whether or not they should.)

But really, the plotting and thematic issues are the least knotty of the problems when it comes to adapting any property that’s rooted deeply in the culture of its creation. I worry, for instance, about the ways in which a whitewashed cast could be justified post facto by this particular project’s setting. Call it the All Cyberbodies Are Grey In The Dark Excuse: after all, in a future where the body is an interchangeable and malleable a commodity as one’s clothes, why wouldn’t you choose to look like ScarJo? Sure, but a) it’s not as if there would be anything wrong with looking like Rinko Kikuchi, either, and b) while that might be the case for the in-universe future presented in the film, such a tap-dance shouldn’t be used as an excuse for ignoring issues of race for the real-world, present-day audience. (Exercise for the reader: How often do Asian markets with healthy film cultures make Western properties with Asiancharacters?)

This is complex stuff and I don’t expect Hollywood to get it, no more so than have been able to in the past. The least I would expect them to do is steer clear of that particular tarpit, and go for properties that don’t have these issues attached to them. Plenty other such properties exist — ones that are lively and creative, which come with a certain amount of fan prestige attached, which already has a degree of separation from the culture of origin, and which are none the worse for being that way. Fullmetal Alchemist, Claymore, Soul Eater, Black Lagoon  — all of which I’ve made cases for in precisely this light — could all make for projects that are at least as profitable and worthy.

It isn’t wholly impossible for Japanese properties to be remade in the West. It just needs to be the right ones. Look at how Seven Samurai was transformed, quite admirably, into The Magnificent Seven. Japan even went us one further by recently producing its own localized remake of Clint Eastwood’s Unforgiven (starring Ken Watanabe, and by all accounts a great film). But Ghost in the Shell is so peculiar to its setting that maybe it’s best to leave it as it is, and look for inspiration elsewhere.

Finally, I shouldn’t make it sound as if Scarlett Johannson herself is the problem. She’s not. She’s a splendid actress, one clearly willing to push herself and try new things (c.f., Under the Skin), and whatever happens to her with this project, I wish her only the best. It’s the project itself that’s misguided, a product of well-intentioned but ultimately wishful thinking. But I suspect it will get made, and that it might even make money thanks to the names involved — and that Hollywood will once again find a way to learn all the wrong lessons from its mistakes.


This article was originally published on Ganriki.

Thanks to our friends at Ganriki for letting us share this content.

Ganriki is a partner in Crossroads Alpha along with Psycho Drive-In.

(Visited 16 times, 1 visits today)

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Share on Tumblr

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Big Eyes Smart MouthGhost in the ShellScarlett JohanssonSerdar Yegulalp

Marvel’s Ant-Man Teaser First Look!
Agent Carter 1.01 “Pilot” & 1.02 “Bridge and Tunnel”

About The Author

monsterid
Serdar Yegulalp
Big Eyes / Smart Mouth
Google+

Serdar Yegulalp (@genjipress) (G+) is Editor-in-Chief of Ganriki.org. He has written about anime professionally as the Anime Guide for Anime.About.com, and as a contributor to Advanced Media Network, but has also been exploring the subject on his own since 1998.

RSSTwitterFacebookinstagramtumblr

Archives

Large_rectangle_336X280
All work on this site is Copyright © each individual writer.
  • PDI Press
    • PDI Press Catalog
    • PDI Press Writers
      • Fiction
  • Columns A-D
    • A Fistful of Dollar Comics
    • ABCs of Horror
    • All Binge… No Purge
    • Anything Joes
    • Beautiful Creatures
    • Big Eyes Smart Mouth
    • Big Sleeps and Long Goodbyes
    • Cahiers du Horror
    • Dispatches From the Field
    • Drive-In Saturday
    • Dungeons & D-Listers
  • Columns F-P
    • The Final Girl
    • First Looks… Second Thoughts
    • The Flesh is Weak
    • Innocence and Experience
    • Lost in Translation
    • Page to Screen
    • Popcorn Cinema
    • Psycho Essentials: The ’80s!
  • Columns S-Z
    • Schlock & Awe
    • Shakespeare on Film
    • Shot for Shot
    • Sick Flix
    • Unnatural Selections
    • Versus
    • Video Word Made Flesh
    • We Got Lists
    • Women in Horror
    • The Xeno File
    • Zombies 101
  • Reviews
    • Books
    • DVD/Blu-ray
    • Movies
    • TV
    • Series
  • Interviews
  • News
    • Trailers
  • Psychos
  • Merchandise
%d bloggers like this: